Scrutinising the Tech Titans: FTC Probes AI Investments by Industry Leaders

Examining the Impact of Tech Giant Investments on Worldwide Technology and Economy

The Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) inquiry into the multibillion-dollar investments by these tech giants in AI startups like OpenAI and Anthropic marks a pivotal moment. 

This inquiry isn't just about the U.S. but sets a precedent that could prompt similar actions from other global entities, including the EU Commission and various national ministries focusing on technology and innovation. The critical question arises: are we witnessing the start of a global revaluation of tech giants' influence in AI and other emerging technologies?

The recent developments around AI investments by tech giants such as Microsoft, Amazon, and Google have sparked discussions on the broader implications for allied nations, including Australia. 

With an external investment exceeding $5 billion in Australia alone, these conglomerates are significantly influencing the pace of tech development, establishing research and development centres worldwide, and exerting a substantial impact on economies and business operations.

2023 was a landmark year showcasing the proliferation of regenerative AI, with OpenAI's ChatGPT at the forefront. This development underscores the urgency for government agencies and independent institutions to catch up and assess the underlying agendas and ethical frameworks of such technologies. 

These AI advancements are not just transforming business-to-business interactions but are also becoming integral to education systems in universities and technical colleges, necessitating a clearer understanding and transparency in their deployment.

The FTC's investigation focuses on how these investment deals by Microsoft, Amazon, and Google could alter the competitive landscape and possibly violate antitrust laws. This action signifies a shift from traditional antitrust lawsuits, which primarily focused on acquisitions and their impact on consumer prices, to a more nuanced approach examining the influence of partnerships and investments in startups.‍

Lina Khan, FTC Chair, asserts that the inquiry aims to understand whether the practices of dominant companies are distorting innovation and undermining fair competition. This is part of Khan's broader agenda to modernise antitrust law application, reflecting a growing awareness of the unique challenges posed by the tech sector.

‍

Internationally, other regulators are also scrutinising these investments. The UK's Competition and Markets Authority and the European Commission are examining the potential impacts on competition and antitrust laws. This global attention highlights the significant role AI investments play in shaping the future of technology and competition.

Tech giants, meanwhile, defend their partnerships as fostering competition and accelerating innovation. Microsoft, for example, has emphasised its partnership with OpenAI as a driver for AI innovation, distinct from a typical acquisition.

However, the FTC's inquiry, along with its other investigations into tech giants' practices, signals a more proactive and comprehensive approach to regulating the technology sector. It acknowledges the need to understand the nuances of AI and its wide-ranging implications on the economy and society.

Peter Schottenfels, a spokesperson for Google, expressed the company's anticipation that the study would highlight practices of certain companies known for customer lock-in, noting a similarity in their approach to AI tool development.

Schottenfels pointed out that unlike Microsoft, which holds an exclusive licence for using OpenAI’s AI models, Google's agreement with Anthropic does not grant exclusive technological rights.

Responses from other major players were more reserved. Both Amazon and OpenAI chose not to comment on the matter, while Anthropic did not respond to inquiries.

Brad Smith, President of Microsoft, shared in a December social media post that their collaboration with OpenAI has been instrumental in promoting AI innovation and competition, emphasising that their partnership maintains the autonomy of both entities and is fundamentally distinct from an outright acquisition.

Regarding regulatory oversight, the FTC and the Justice Department have traditionally shared the responsibility of investigating antitrust violations by tech giants. The FTC has been active in this area, having brought antitrust legal actions against Amazon and Meta. The Justice Department, on its part, has pursued legal action against Google and is currently probing Apple's practices.

The FTC is also known for its capability to generate comprehensive public reports examining specific corporate behaviours and their economic impacts. A notable example from 2021 is a report analysing the acquisition patterns of tech giants, concluding that many of these acquisitions did not trigger mandatory government review thresholds. More recently, the agency has been probing into how social media and video platforms manage deceptive advertising.

The dynamics between leading tech firms and AI startups have come under intense scrutiny, especially after notable events at OpenAI, including the temporary exit of CEO Sam Altman. During this tumultuous phase, Microsoft's CEO Satya Nadella played a significant advisory role to Altman, even proposing to integrate Altman and his team into Microsoft.

These developments have sparked concerns about Microsoft's potential influence over OpenAI's decision-making processes, although Altman ultimately returned to his position at OpenAI.

This situation underscores the growing importance of regulatory oversight, particularly in closely allied nations like Australia and the UK. These developments could very well pave the way for increased scrutiny, government interventions, and public disclosures regarding the relationships between tech giants and emerging AI enterprises.

Such actions are vital in ensuring that technological advancements, especially in influential fields like AI, are developed and utilised responsibly and ethically. These outcomes will be crucial in reinforcing the principles of ethical practice and competitive fairness within the rapidly evolving tech industry, with potential far-reaching impacts on allies like Australia and the UK, who are keenly observing these developments.

As the global community progresses, there is an urgent need for a collaborative and well-informed dialogue among regulators, businesses, and other key players about technology's evolving role in society. The results of these ongoing inquiries and studies are poised to significantly influence the direction of AI development and its assimilation into the international economy.